Bach: B Minor Mass
|
List Price:
$23.98
Hungary Hotels Travel Price: $23.98
Subject To Change Without Notice
Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours
Manufacturer: RCA
|
Average Customer Rating:  
|
|
Binding: Audio CD
EAN: 0090266352920
Label: RCA
Manufacturer: RCA
Number Of Discs: 2
Publisher: RCA
Release Date: 1999-10-12
Studio: RCA
|
|
|
|
|
|
Spotlight customer reviews:
|
Customer Rating:
Summary: A Fantastic Blend
Comment: This is an amazing recording. I want to say that I also own Klemperer and Gardiner's "definitive" recordings, one being ultra-romantic, the other being the polar opposite period performance. Both are fantastic in their own way; however, after a while with only "extremes" I felt I needed a blend. I knew just where to go. I bought this fantastic recording off Amazon, and was not disappointed. It does not have the blazing speed of Gardiner's recording, yet is never lethargic in places (as one could easily say about Klemperers). Overall, the tempos are perfect, with a mastery blend of quickness in the faster sections, and restrained romanticism in the slower ones. I also believe that this version surpasses Shaw's later, more restrained, 1990 version with Telarc; for while the latter recording's sonics are better, the earlier recording makes up for its technological flaws (which are not bad at all - it is Living Stereo) with intensity and spontaneity. Will I stop listing to Gardiner's or Klemperer's conceptions now that I have found my blend? - No, they are both brilliant in their own way, and "definitive" seems to be a fitting adjective for the beauty contained within each set. However, the B Minor Mass is one of the supreme achievements of Western music, and to have but one interpretation is doing yourself a great injustice. Robert Shaw's conception of Bach's masterpiece is just what I wanted, and this testament should be in every music lover's collection.
Customer Rating:
Summary: Hmmm...inconsistency in the last review?
Comment: Forgive me if I did not catch the irony, but on first appearance the previous review (by wilbod) presents an intense philosophical discourse on the rediculousness and intellectual dishonesty in claiming one can "know" how baroque music was performed in its day. Yet it is followed by the claim that this recording is somehow "100% historically accurate!"
In actuality, no artist or period existed in a vaccum. Its philosophical, theological, and cultural context determined its "style." Now while it is quite true that we have no samples of playing from the baroque period, we have the intellectual and theological framework in which it was birthed. We also have written descriptions (by musicians and musicologists as well as common fans of music) describing the texture and the sound in very specific terms. All those PhD's that wilbod condemns are not idiots, and their claims about discovering authentic aesthetics are not just coming from the air...
Anyway...any conductor that tries to infuse this music with Romantic sensibility is committing a crime. The theological degredation that happened between the Baroque and Romantic periods is shocking and to think these forms are similar or can co-exist in a single work let alone the classification of "classical music" is saying that light and darkness co-exist in a single room. This is madness.
Customer Rating:
Summary: Politically Incorrect Bach... and ain't it Grand!
Comment: I'm so happy this made it to CD, I'll park it next to my recordings of Beecham's Messiah, Oistrach's Bach violin concerti, Lehmann's Water Music, and Klemperer's Brandenburgs!
For too many years Baroque music was considered to be busy counterpoint-heavy, knitting-machine stuff. It had an undeserved bad rep similar to what Schoenberg's music has had now for a long while. Too intellectual, too academic, too remote.
By the middle of the Twentieth Century (The Age of Reason) some who saw great merit, commercial or otherwise, in Baroque music presented it to the public in a way that seemed perfectly legitimate, a way that, however, and in actuality, matched more the mood of the time and the needs of the market. You see, contemporary music of that era was already way too intellectual and academic, and "Romantic" music had fallen into disfavor since WWI. In 1960 only retired and somewhat suspect Teutons enjoyed the excesses of Wagner and Strauss, usually while wearing battered old helmets.
A romanticized Baroque was the perfect option, permitting lush romanticism within the context of an acceptable and rigorously worked-out intellectualized framework. The music was smart, stylish, and "cool" in a Stravinsky/Modern Jazz Quartet sort of way while still managing to be somewhat languorous and sexy. By the Seventies of course everyone was shooting for "historical accuracy," in other words trying to make Baroque music sound like Phil Glass and Steve Reich-like Rock and Roll.
Nobody cares to admit that we really have no idea how this music is supposed to sound. Doctorates are built on delusions about this subject. We can be dead certain that if some scholar finds out exactly how it's supposed to sound and that sound is, by modern standards, pretty repulsive, we won't see a big drive to alter currently accepted performance practices. Get my point? Right now we're seeing a backlash against period instrument performances--they sound awful--so we're back to modern instruments to give the music more of a contemporary Alternative Music sound.
So what you have here with this recording is the 1960 idea of what life was like in 1735 or so. If you think about that for a minute it's an absurdity and unfortunately one that only becomes obvious to its perpetrators after a few years have slid by. Humility takes time and we hep cats of 2005 will eventually realize that all our smug certainties, like those of our ancestors, were only so much spin and wind. Anyway, this is an absolutely 100% certifiably historically accurate 1961 performance of Bach. It's really quite beautiful by any standards-Bach might have even liked it, maybe even Mozart and Schoenberg-and it's quite moving. To this day it's about the only Mass in B Minor recording that I can actually relax to and enjoy. More recent ones sound too, well, artsy and Punkish, kind of pre-9/11. Can't recommend it enough!
Customer Rating:
Summary: ***THERE ARE NO OTHER RECORDINGS LIKE THIS**
Comment: From the opening "Kyrie Eleison", which you will feel down to your feet, to the closing "Dona Nobis Pacem" this CD will blow
your mind. I own the original LP which I happened to find at a used book store in South Philly for $7.00! You MUST play this
as loud as possible. It is earth shatteringly beautiful, sensitive, and leaves me breathless every time I listen to it.
Lucky for you this is on CD! I'm sending a copy to my mother right now!
ENJOY!!!!!
Customer Rating:
Summary: Wonderful Performance with Draw backs yes...
Comment: I understand that this recording sounds a little muddy, but what do you expect?! ITS A HISTORIC RECORDING! Robert Shaw and Company recorded this album in 1960. It was THE FIRST AND ONLY recording of the B Minor Mass in the USA, for years! There is a reason why it won th 1960 Grammy Award for Best Choral Recording. Robert Shaw and company went all over the country in 1960 performing this piece in Farm Houses and School Gyms. Bringing this piece of Baroque Mastery to the numberless masses. Accounts of the day talk about people waiting in lines for 10 to 12 hours to hear this group perform THIS PIECE! Dogging this recording for bad recording practices is ok. I will give you that the sound is not crystal clear. But the performance of Chours, Soloist and Orchestra are OUTSTANDING. Know why this piece and this recording had the praise and acclades it had for so long. Own this CD and Own a Piece of History!
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Hungary Trips Books
Hungary Trips DVD
Hungary Trips Softwares
Hungary Trips Magazines
Hungary Posters
Hungary Art Prints
Hungary Travel 2007 Calendars
2007 Monthly Calendars
Hungary Hotels Travel Special Resources
Hungary Arts
Hungary Entertainment
Hungary Government
Hungary Business
Hungary Culture
Hungary Education
Hungary Health
Hungary Map
Hungary Beach
Hungary Festivals
Hungary Hotels
Hungary Museums
Hungary Theme Parks
Hungary Transportation
Food and Recipes
Sports & Recreation
Travel & Tourism
Hungary Destinations
Budapest, Hungary
Heviz, Hungary
Sopron, Hungary
Eger, Hungary
Szeged, Hungary
Lake Balaton, Hungary
Hungary Hotels
Budapest Hotels
Heviz Hotels
Sopron Hotels
Szeged Hotels
|
Hungary Hotels Travel
Maintained by: Marketer Solutions | Link Building
